This morning, the day after
Flickr officially integrated video sharing capabilities into their site, I received an invitation to join a new Flickr group called "
We Say NO to Videos on Flickr." The group's mission states:
Let youtube have the video and Flickr have the photos or if Yahoo wants videos create a seperate page. Don't become another Facebook or Myspace!! What next Ad's on each page? Please keep flickr for Photographers - Photographers don't want FLICKR flooded with random 'video phone' style videos. Give us the choice on whether we see video. All members of his group say NO.
The formation of groups like this one is a common form of protest on Flickr; the tactic was used several months ago when Flickr changed its rules about censoring photos containing graphic nudity or other content that may be perceived as "inappropriate" from being default-uncensored to being default-censored.
I would say that of the flagship websites of the social media revolution, Flickr has probably had the best record of actively listening to its community, and only evolving in measured steps along with the interests and desires of its users.
When I first heard about the addition of video to Flickr I was definitely apprehensive. As the popularity and accessibility of digital photography has exploded, Flickr has managed to maintain a relatively high level of quality. In an online world awash in poorly lit cameraphone party pics, Flickr has somehow managed to cultivate a thriving culture of aesthetic idealism, an environment where every participant is compelled to share their best work - regardless of their personal level of expertise.
So, after reading Flickr's own take on how they want video to be incorporated into their site:
You can now share videos up to 90 glorious seconds in your photostream. 90 seconds? While this might seem like an arbitrary limit, we thought long and hard about how video would complement the flickrverse. If you’ve memorized the Community Guidelines, you know that Flickr is all about sharing photos that you yourself have taken. Video will be no different and so what quickly bubbled up was the idea of “long photos,” of capturing slices of life to share.
I'm willing to give them the benefit of the doubt; and I look forward to seeing how my favorite photographers make the most of this new channel for creativity and expression.